Bigcommerce vs. Magento 2: Which one is best for my online start-up Business?

Choosing the right platform is crucial for your online startup’s success. But with giants like BigCommerce and Adobe Commerce (Magento 2), the decision can be overwhelming. This post will break down each platform’s key features, pricing, and suitability, helping you pick the perfect match for your business.

These two platforms hold a substantial market share and are favored among merchants seeking to establish a robust online presence. At the same time, both BigCommerce and Adobe Commerce (Magento) provide a solid foundation for e-commerce mid-scale and large-scale covering all industries of B2C, D2C, and B2B.

Read Also: Volusion vs. BigCommerce – What’s better, Volusion or BigCommerce?

Folio3 is a certified BigCommerce agency & technology partner with Adobe commerce certified developers, so we are well-versed in the ins and outs of both platforms.

Before we kick things off, though, here’s how the two builders stack up in terms of performance:

Bigcommerce vs. Magento 2 – At a Glance

Now that we’ve set the stage for the Magento vs BigCommerce showdown, let’s take a closer look at these two e-commerce giants. Understanding their core attributes will lay the foundation for a more detailed exploration.

BigCommerce and Adobe Comparison You can check the details and latest prices on the official BigCommerce pricing page (https://www.bigcommerce.com/essentials/pricing/).
Feature	BigCommerce (Standard, Plus, and, Pro)	BigCommerce Enterprise	Adobe Commerce Community Edition	Adobe Commerce Cloud
		General Features
Target Audience	Small-scale	Mid-Market, High-Volume & Complex Businesses	Mid-Market, High-Volume & Complex Businesses	Mid-Market, High-Volume & Complex Businesses
Pricing	Standard: $39/month Plus: $105/month Pro: $399/month	Custom Pricing Depends on monthly volume of orders	Open source	Custom Pricing
Hosting	√	√	Self-hosted	√ *Self-hosted if On-premise
Free SSL certificate	√	√		√ *No if On-Premise
Secure payment gateways	– Several are provided are out of the box – Extensions are also available on Marketplace	– Several are provided are out of the box – Extensions are also available on Marketplace	– Several are provided are out of the box – Extensions are also available on Marketplace	– Several are provided are out of the box – Extensions are also available on Marketplace
Minimum Monthly Volume		Tiers are defined based on monthly/annual orders.		Tiers are defined based on monthly/annual orders.
Security Patches / Version Upgrades	√ Automatically catered	√ Automatically catered	– Need to upgrade or apply manually with the involvement of the Development Team	– Need to upgrade or apply manually with the involvement of the Development Team
Scalability & Flexibility	High	High	Depend on Self-hosting	High (Dependent on Self-Hosting If On-Prem)
Products	Unlimited	Unlimited	Unlimited	Unlimited
Storage	Unlimited	Unlimited	Depend on Self-hosting	Unlimited (*N/A (Depends on hosting if on-prem)
Bandwidth	Unlimited	Unlimited	Depend on Self-hosting	Unlimited (*N/A (Depends on hosting if on-prem)
Abandoned Cart Saver	√ (Not available in Standard plan)	√	X	√ (Cart Persistence)
Stored Credit Cards	X	X	X	X
Customer Groups	Unlimited	Unlimited	Unlimited	Unlimited
API Access	Full	Full	Full	Full
Customizable Checkout	√ (If custom checkout SDK is used)	√ (If custom checkout SDK is used)	√ Customizable	√ Customizable
Discount Codes	Unlimited	Unlimited	Unlimited	Unlimited
Gift Cards	√	√	√	√
Multi-Currency	Multi-Currency is supported by some payment gateways. Details can be found here: LINK	Multi-Currency is supported by some payment gateways. Details can be found here: LINK	This can be done via multiple store views	This can be done via multiple store views
Blog capabilities	√	√	X	X
Language Translation	√	√	√	√
Currency conversion	√	√	√	√
24 x 7 Customer Support	√	√	X	√ *No if On-Premise

While this comparison highlights some key attributes to consider when choosing an e-commerce platform, it’s important to remember that both platforms offer a wider range of features. The best platform for you ultimately depends on your specific needs and requirements.

B2B Functionality:

Both platforms offer modules or features suitable for B2B businesses. However, it’s crucial to note that B2B features are typically only available in their higher tiers:

– BigCommerce: B2B features are available in BigCommerce Enterprise editions.

– Adobe Commerce: B2B features are included in Adobe Commerce On-premises (formerly Magento 2 Enterprise) and Adobe Commerce Cloud versions.

Exploring the specific B2B features of each platform would be beneficial in choosing the one that best aligns with your needs.

BigCommerce and Adobe Comparison
Feature	BigCommerce Enterprise	Adobe Commerce On-premises & Cloud
B2B Features
Company Accounts	√	√
Request for Quote	√	√
Quick/Bulk Order Form	√	√
Quick Re-order / Buy Again	√	√
Sales Rep Masquerade	√	– There is a feature in the B2B module as “Sales representative initiate the quote”. LINK
Assign SalesRep to the Company	√	√
Invoice Payments / Net terms	√	X
Automatic Company Approval	√	X
Shared Company Addresses	√	X
Customization	Buyer Portal will be open-sourced in Q2/Q3 2024	Customizable

Making the Right Choice

Well, in this comprehensive comparison between BigCommerce vs Magento, we’ve examined the strengths and features of each platform to help you make an informed decision that aligns with your business goals. Let’s wrap up this discussion by offering some clear guidance on which platform suits which type of business best.

You Should Use BigCommerce If….	You Should Use Magento If…
You value easy setup, with all the tools you need already at your disposal	You have an in-house tech team or a tech partner on board
You’re not massively tech-savvy	You’re happy to take on a larger project when it comes to your online store
You want to sell across multiple channels, including social media (eg Facebook)	You are looking for extensive customizations in the core platform to suit your business needs
You want to avoid the hassle of hosting, frequent updates and security considerations.	You are looking to have full control over your store’s hosting and infrastructure.

At Folio3, we understand that this decision is a critical one for your business. That’s why we’re here to offer our expertise in Magento and BigCommerce development. Whether you choose Magento or BigCommerce, we are committed to providing you with expert, reliable, and affordable Bigcommerce e-commerce development solutions. Reach out to us today to explore how our services can help your online business thrive.

Read Also: BigCommerce vs. Competitor Platforms – Which One Is Right for You?